One night I was hanging out with my nerdy friend, Andrew, in his older brother James’ basement. We were looking at some novelty items I got from a swag bag I was given at a party I had attended. One of them was a pair of handcuffs. Suddenly, Andrew received a text, and a beaming smile came on his face. Andrew looked over at me and with a look of mischief on his face, picked up the handcuffs and asked if he could put them on me, promising to take them off at some point. Not seeing the harm and assuming ‘at some point’ meant ‘right away,’ I let him, placing my hands behind my back. I hadn’t expected Andrew to get suddenly aggressive and push me onto the couch, stomach-first.

Cuckold Humiliation Stories: After Leaving Me Hogtied in the Basement, My Friends Took My Girlfriend Upstairs

“What are you doing?” I asked my geeky buddy, confused.

“Eh…I just need you out of the way for a while-ah…” Andrew replied, leaving me perplexed.

Suddenly, James and his friend, Mike, came downstairs. I felt like I wasn’t cool enough to hang with them the moment I laid eyes on the pair of alpha males…like I was on Andrew’s level. Andrew pointed to my handcuffs, muttering something I couldn’t hear to both Mike and James, which made the three of them laugh mischievously. Andrew had a smirk on his face, while Mike and James had boyish grins on theirs.

My Friends Hogtied Me in the Basement and Gangbangd My Girlfriend
For more pics in this series see “Haze Him“.

Just then, my girlfriend, Amy, and her friend Ashley came down and joined us. She was dressed up to the nines, more than she had ever dressed up for me. Amy looked radiant – her hair was done up, her dress showing a lot of cleavage, and I suspected she wasn’t wearing any underwear. I knew my girlfriend was hanging out with Ashley that night but was surprised to see the ladies hanging out with my friends. It seems that Mike and James had plans to watch a hockey game on TV and invited the girls over to join them. James made a point of telling me that my girlfriend specifically asked for Andrew to come.

Meanwhile, Mike told Amy about Andrew handcuffing me, which made them both laugh in my direction. The boys talked to each other with their voices intentionally low, so I couldn’t hear them before the trio walked over to me with sinister intentions written all over their faces.

“Eh…where should we dump ‘em-ah?” Andrew asked Mike and James while standing behind me.

“Just leave him here,” Mike said, thumbing to the sofa to my right.

“Well, let’s have a little fun first, shall we?” James said to them with a shit-eating grin.

With James holding my legs, Andrew began tying my legs together with some rope and duct tape he had in the tool room nearby. My legs and arms were now bent and touching each other – the boys had hogtied me. Everyone was laughing at the mess I had allowed myself to get into.

“Alright, let’s get outta here,” Mike said to the group, leading them all upstairs.

Buddies Hogtied Me and Gangbanged My Girlfriend
For more pics of Monica Scott, Mike Burry, Brady Quinn, and Sean Costin see “Hot Guys Fuck: Group Fuck in Foursome”.

“See ya, chump,” James said with a smirk.

My girl was about to approach me first, but Andrew put his arm around her shoulder and whispered something in her ear to make her blush. Suddenly, all her attention was on him. Andrew gave me a thumbs-up and a wink before leading my girl upstairs.

My Friends Duct-Taped My Mouth and Hogtied Me Before Fucking My Girlfriend
For more pics in this series see “FraternityX: Fratboy Tied Up“.

I remained hogtied, unable to break free for what seemed like forever. After hearing nothing but muffled voices, music, and laughter, things quieted own before furniture started squeaking on the floor as if couches were being pushed in thrusts. I heard girls screaming, shouting in excitement, and the guys were shouting profanities, cheering one another on like they were at a football game.

The laughter had turned into silence, followed by moaning and groaning from the boys. I could hear Andrew sighing, and rolled my eyes, as I knew he made that sound whenever he beat off. I wondered why he would make such noises in the presence of others, though. I couldn’t hear Amy talk at all, but heard her making odd sounds like she was slobbering all over a Popsicle while being rhythmically pushed around backward and forwards. At one point, all the boys exhaled aggressively, followed by panting and sighing. I wasn’t an idiot; I figured out what was happening. They were obviously watching the hockey game. The way the noise ceased suggested that the home team had lost.

My Girlfriend Partied with My Friend While I Remained Hogtied in the Basement

Shortly afterward, I heard three people exit the house. Andrew and Mike came downstairs and told me James was taking the girls home. The boys had smiles on their faces you couldn’t have scrubbed off. They had clearly done something and were purposely not telling me what it was. That made me feel as if something happened at my expense. I felt as if the joke was on me, though I had no idea what the joke’ was.

Andrew smacked me on the cheek a few times before ripping the duct tape from my mouth and setting me free from the ropes and handcuffs.

Friends Hogtied Me and Fucked My Girl
For more pics in this series see “FraternityX“.

“Why didn’t Amy come down to get me before she left?” I asked the two of them.

“We made a mess out of her,” Mike said smiling, making the jerk-off motion with his fist to Andrew. The two of them fist-bumped, which as surreal to me. As far as I was concerned, Mike was the alpha male and Andrew was a total beta. The two of them laughing together made me feel like the uncool kid among the popular ones. Further, they didn’t even apologize for the predicament I was left in all night.

My Friends Dumped Cum All Over My Girlfriend While I Was Hogtied
For more pics of Pepper Xo see “Step Siblings Caught: Fleshlight Delivery

“Eh…your girlfriend is a real hands-on type of person-ah,” Andrew said grinning, looking down at me as I tried to get the blood circulating in my now-free wrists.

“What do you mean?” I asked, dumbfounded.

“Eh…I mean she needed two hands to hold me—ah…” Andrew replied while giving me a few light slaps on the cheek again before walking upstairs. I felt like was mocking me, but I was oblivious to whatever he was acknowledging.

My Girlfriend Gave My Buddy a Handjob While I Was Hogtied Downstairs
For more pics of Monica Scott and Kyle Dean see “Hot Guys Fuck: Teen Muscle Stud Fucks Brunette Babe“.

I followed Andrew upstairs when suddenly, Mike pulled me aside and told me what a mess the place had turned into. Andrew appeared to my right, a smirk on his face, a garbage bag in one hand, a broom in the other.

“Eh…make yourself useful and clean the place up-ah,” Andrew said to me.

“Good idea,” Mike said to me while winking at Andrew. “Might have a little surprise for ya if you do a decent job, buddy.”

“Eh…keyword being IF,” Andrew said to me with an authoritative tone. “Make sure the place is neat and tidy before James gets back.”

I grabbed the broom and garbage bag from Andrew and began tidying up, angry that I was the only one doing so. I felt like Andrew should have been the clean-up boy. He was the beta male out of the four of us…wasn’t he?

It took me about 10 minutes to clean up the mess that was left behind. Dishes were put in the dishwasher, food placed back in the fridge, and the floors were swept. I took out the garbage when I spotted something between a pair of seat cushions. I picked it up and realized it was a pair of panties, coincidentally the kind my girlfriend liked to wear. In fact, I was sure I saw her put on that same pair earlier that morning. I figured Amy’s panty choices were popular amongst hot women.

As I finished cleaning up, Andrew, much to my surprise, handed me a full bottle of beer, already opened, telling me I deserved a drink. He apologized for the beer being warm, as it was apparently taken out of the fridge and not placed back in. It was the only one left, and Mike was going to drink it but decided to give it to me instead. His explanation of why the bottle wasn’t cold and why it was opened seemed insincere, especially since Andrew was laughing while Mike was explaining all this to me, but whatever. I saw it as a peace offering of sorts. I thanked the boys and chugged the beer, which, for some reason, made both Andrew and Mike break out laughing once again. The beer tasted just as bad as the one I drank earlier, smelled just as rancid, and left a foul aftertaste on my breath.

Andrew pointed to a bottle of Jack Daniels on the counter and told me to polish it off.

“Eh…that’ll help you wash down the taste of us-ah,” Andrew said to me.

“Us?” I replied.

“Naw, don’t give him the JD,” Mike said, taking the bottle away. “Let him appreciate the taste.” The boys high-fived and laughed once again. What was so funny?!

When I left, I sent a text to Amy asking if she got home okay. She told me she was fine, but that she wasn’t interested in being my girlfriend anymore. Seriously, she as text-dumping me?! I asked her why she suddenly had such a change of heart about me.

She then sent me a link to the footage Mike recorded earlier of Andrew pouring beer down my mouth while I was tied up. She left me no verbal explanation, no reason, and no apologies. Just like that, my relationship with Amy was over. I didn’t get the vibe that she was heartbroken about it, either. Whatever happened between Mike, James, and Andrew, it put an end to what she and I had together.